Descartes arrived in the Dutch Republic at the end of 1628 and, apart from three visits to France in the 1640s, stayed until he left for Sweden in 1649. Every one of his major books was written there. Most of us in the circle live within an hour's train ride of somewhere he once lodged, which is one of the reasons we started reading him.
Liberty and anonymity
He explained the choice himself. In a letter of May 1631 to his friend Jean-Louis Guez de Balzac he describes Amsterdam as a town where everyone except himself is busy with trade and so preoccupied with profit that he could live there all his life without being noticed. He compares the ships bringing in goods from the Indies to the orchards and gardens Balzac enjoyed in the country, and asks where else one could find such complete liberty.
Holland gave him freedom of a particular kind: a country where people left you alone, where books could be printed, and where the post to Paris was reliable enough to keep up a correspondence with Mersenne. The Discourse was printed in Leiden; the Principles in Amsterdam by the Elzevirs.
On the move
He also moved constantly, by one count well over a dozen times. The record is patchy, since he did not always tell even his friends where he was, but it includes:
- Franeker, in Friesland, where he enrolled at the university in 1629 and began a short treatise on metaphysics;
- Amsterdam, at several addresses in the early 1630s, close to the butchers from whom he bought carcasses to dissect;
- Leiden, where he enrolled to attend lectures in mathematics in 1630 and whose printers published the Discourse;
- Deventer and Utrecht in the mid-1630s; his daughter Francine was born in Deventer in 1635;
- Santpoort, near Haarlem, in the late 1630s;
- the small castle of Endegeest, near Leiden, from 1641 to 1643;
- and finally Egmond, near the North Sea coast, from 1643 until he left for Stockholm.
Not always peaceful
The Dutch universities were where Cartesian philosophy was first taught, and also where it was first condemned. At Utrecht, the professor of medicine Henricus Regius took up the new philosophy with enthusiasm; the theologian Gisbertus Voetius, rector of the university, attacked it as dangerous to faith, and in 1642 the university's senate formally rejected it. The quarrel spread to Leiden and lasted for years. Descartes, who had come for quiet, ended up writing long public letters in his own defence.
Quel autre pays où l’on puisse jouir d’une liberté si entière ?What other country is there where one can enjoy such complete freedom? — Letter to Balzac, 5 May 1631
A walk, if you are nearby
Several of the houses still stand. In Amsterdam a plaque at Westermarkt 6 marks a house where he lived in 1634. Endegeest is now surrounded by a park. We hold one summer session each year somewhere on the list; suggestions for next year are welcome at the end of any meeting.